Zum Inhalt

Private sales on online platforms

When do I become a trader?

A natural person who simultaneously publishes several ads for new or used goods on a website, can only be considered to be an "entrepreneur" if this person acts in the framework of a commercial, professional or craft activity.

The case

A consumer buys a watch on an online platform. The seller placed a total of eight ads for diverse - new and used - goods, under a pseudonym. The question was, whether the seller was acting as an entrepreneur and if therefore the protective provisions for consumer businesses would apply (e.g. comprehensive information duties, right to withdrawal).

What is decisive is whether the seller acted within the scope of commercial, craft or professional activities or on behalf of an entrepreneur or trader. This has to be decided from case to case, which means that the (Bulgarian) court in charge of this case has to evaluate all the relevant information presented.

Assessment of the CJEU

However, the European Court of Justice (CJEU) created a set of criteria that have to be considered by the court. Those are neither exclusive nor restrictive, which means that the fulfilment of one or more of those criteria alone is not sufficient to classify an online seller as an entrepreneur (e.g. if the sale had the purpose to make profit or if the seller published several ads one the online platform).

This article was first published by the legal department of the Austrian consumer association (VKI) and translated by ECC Austria. Read the full verdict in English at the website of the CJEU.

Find out more about your rights as a consumer in our section regarding online shopping.

Share this post

Facebook Twitter Drucken E-Mail

This could also be of interest:

Postpakete auf dem Förderband

No more €22 tax-free allowance for EU imports

As of today, 1 July 2021, the tax exemption for imports into the EU no longer applies to goods with a value of less than 22 euros. We describe what price increases and also improvements this means for end customers.

Screenshot of the Eikora website with warning pictogram in the foreground

Warning: eikora.de does not deliver

Numerous complaints have been made to ECC-Net and also to other consumer protection organisations about German online suppliers of bathroom fittings and furniture. The number of problem cases has risen sharply since the end of 2020, better order elsewhere!

Parcel service delivery agent scans code of an Amazon parcel

Amazon non-delivery problems

If a parcel ordered on Amazon has not arrived, but it has been registered as delivered by the delivery person, Amazon would like to have a police confirmation that the investigation has been completed. In Austria, however, you can only file a complaint with the police. Read what to do.

alt

Webshop Home24 SE

Wrong delivery and stalling tactics, after frequent complaints we advise against ordering from the German online furniture mail order company Home24.

alt

Brexit: Scam with small ads

Brexit is not just concerning international politicians. Fraudsters are now increasingly using the UK's exit from the EU for their schemes on the internet.

Sozialministerium
VKI
EU
ECC
Zum Seitenanfang